Skip to main content

School of Philosophy

  • Home
  • People
  • Events
    • Event series
    • Conferences
      • Past conferences
    • Past events
  • News
    • Audio/Video Recordings
  • Research
  • Study with us
    • Prizes and scholarships
  • Visit us
  • Contact us

Centres & Projects

  • Centre for Consciousness
  • Centre for Moral, Social and Political Theory
  • Centre for Philosophy of the Sciences
  • Humanising Machine Intelligence

Related Sites

  • Research School of Social Sciences
  • ANU College of Arts & Social Sciences

Centre for Consciousness

Related Sites

Centre for Moral, Social and Political Theory

Centre for Philosophy of the Sciences

School of Philosophy

Administrator

Breadcrumb

HomeUpcoming EventsI'm Mistaken
I'm mistaken

Abstract: I know that not everything I believe is true -- no one is right about everything. Does this mean, or at least strongly suggest, that my beliefs are inconsistent? Inspired by Makinson's (1965) celebrated preface paradox, many epistemologists have thought that it does. In this talk I will argue that it doesn't. I begin by presenting the puzzle of modesty -- I prove that, anyone who knows what they do and don't believe cannot be both modest and consistent. But the implications of this puzzle are unclear, because (i) ordinary people are not perfectly introspective, and (ii) even highly demanding notions of ideal rationality shouldn't require agents to know what they don't believe. Following up on (i), explain why Makinson's preface case doesn't show that ordinary people have inconsistent beliefs, and that in variants of the case where ordinary people do have inconsistent beliefs this has nothing to do with their being modest. Following up on (ii), I give a model showing how, appropriately understood, logically and introspectively perfect agents can consistently believe that they have false beliefs.

Zoom details:
https://anu.zoom.us/j/81629981396?pwd=WTBuWGpqeGg5UjF3RFllekZqaFJIZz09
 
Meeting ID: 816 2998 1396
Password: 257004

Upcoming PhilSocs:
22.11: Brandon Yip (grads only)
29.11: Pamela Robinson

Date & time

  • Tue 15 Nov 2022, 3:00 pm - 4:30 pm

Location

RSSS Room 6.71, Level 5, RSSS Building, ANU, 146 Ellery Crescent, Acton, ACT 2601

Speakers

  • Jeremy Goodman

Event Series

Philsoc seminars

Contact

  •  Aidan Ryall
     Send email